This thing's gotten over 260,000 five-star reviews ... I mean, there is a reason why this mascara is a top seller at Amazon. Reviewers of all ages love the falsie effect as much as I do.

As a regular WWD Shop tester and beauty product reviewer, I've tested over 100 mascaras (yes, really) from practically every beauty retailer, including cult-favorite prestige formulas, TikTok ...

“[Women over 40] tend to lose our eyelashes ... more prominent—no matter your skin tone or eye color. Add the top-rated mascara to your cart now, and make sure to check out more of Geller ...